The public has been buzzing over a recent photo of Kate Middleton, which was published by the American tabloid TMZ. Despite not being shared by any British tabloids, the photo quickly made its way to social media, showing Kate wearing sunglasses in the passenger seat of a car.

After her “planned” abdominal surgery, the palace had cleared Kate’s schedule, leading the public to get excited when it was initially announced that she would make an earlier-than-expected public appearance. This was confirmed when the Minister of Defense stated that Kate Middleton would attend the Trooping the Colour dress rehearsal on June 8, ahead of the main event on June 15.

However, it was later revealed that this was a mistake, and the announcement of Kate’s potential royal duty return was removed from an Army website. According to GB News, Kensington Palace was “not consulted” about the Princess of Wales’ scheduled appearance.

The photo of Kate, published in American media, sparked even more speculation about her health. While the Palace tried to protect her privacy, the leaked photo has been seen as a failure in handling the situation.

Jack Royston, Newsweek’s chief royal correspondent, blamed the Palace for fueling speculation by being overly secretive. He explained that the secrecy created demand for the photo, leading to a financial incentive for photographers to take risks.

He said the Palace could have stopped the speculation earlier by simply providing a photo or video, even a casual one.

Jack Royston pointed out that by not addressing it sooner, the situation escalated, and they ended up not protecting Kate. While they thought they were shielding her, the media attention only worsened, and she wouldn’t feel protected.

Other experts believe the entire thing has been fishy from the start.

Christopher Andersen, author of The King, believes that if Kate is truly recovering as the Palace claims, she should have made a public appearance, even if just to smile for the cameras. He noted that royal family members always maintain appearances, citing Queen Elizabeth’s ability to keep working despite health issues. Andersen speculated that while Kate might prefer privacy, her prolonged absence has sparked curiosity about the real situation.

Daniela Elser believes that the TMZ photo hides a deeper story.

“With these new images, it’s depressing that it looks a lot like Kate felt she had to let her face be seen in public to stem the tide of delirium. There is something just a bit screwy and upsetting and off-kilter about the internet rabble being able to alter the plan for the 42-year-old’s recovery.”

She argued that Prince William should take responsibility for the situation he helped create, instead of leaving it to Kate, who had significant surgery and was recovering in the hospital.

Elser questioned whether the photo showed a woman ready to return to public life or just another display for the public.

She concluded that, despite the luxury, true freedom and independence might not exist, even with a grand estate.